Project context
Reconstruction of the 108th Street pumping station in New York City for the NYC Department of Environmental Protection under Contract PS-277: replacement of pumps, generators, electrical, HVAC and odour control systems, with an interim pump station keeping the service running during the works.
Who we supported
The owner side. Our team worked with the owner’s construction management team to test the contractor’s delay position.
The issue
The contractor reported growing delay in successive monthly updates and attributed it to mobilisation approvals and a long series of change orders. The owner needed to know how much of the delay the contractor was entitled to, and how much was its own.
Records reviewed
- Approved baseline and 22 monthly schedule updates
- Change order records, from issue through proposal, negotiation, approval and registration
- RFIs and the contractor’s notices of delay
- Construction management records of event dates and durations
Analysis approach and why
Windows analysis across 11 windows, each bounded by accepted schedule updates. In each window the delay events were inserted into the earlier update and compared with the next one, to separate excusable delay, contractor delay and contractor mitigation. Each update was checked for logic and duration changes before use, and event dates were checked against the construction management records. We used windows analysis because a full series of contemporaneous updates was available and the owner needed liability by period, not a single global figure.
Deliverables
- Schedule delay analysis report
- Window-by-window liability summary: entitlement, contractor delay and mitigation
- Update-by-update change review covering added activities, logic changes and duration changes
Status
Report issued at the February 2024 data date to support the owner’s assessment. Any final determination is not recorded in the documents available to us.
Representative photo: Steven Olswang / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0





























